June 24, 2025
There's a big feature in Sunday's New York Times Magazine on writing history with the assistance of AI and it underscores many of our main concerns. My favorite line in the piece is an editor who became disturbed by how easy it was for AI to regurgitate bad information, saying, "that's what AI can't do. It has no bullshit detector."
Speaking of BS, here is a new trend that really grinds me.
And, here is an AI concoction circulating online attempting to capture the same camp.
There is a new book The Gunfighters, by Bryan Burrough that has Jesse James killing bank teller Joseph Heywood in the failed Northfield, Minnesota bank raid in September of 1876. This is a long disproved belief perpetrated by early biographers who wanted it to be Jesse. In fact there is a sworn affidavit of bank employee Frank Wilcox that identifies Frank James as Heywood's killer, and this after Wilcox made a special trip to the Independence jail to observe Frank in person. In addition, Cole Younger, on his death bed, admitted to Jesse Jr. that the rider of the dun horse was Frank James, and that it was Frank who killed the bank teller. Two things possibly happened: Burrough didn't dig deep enough (he sites T.J. Stiles' book, "Jesse James: Last Rebel of the Civil War" in his bibliography and Stiles names Jesse as the killer). Or, the AI sided with Stiles, and, it's in this fulcrum of competing "facts" that AI is not quite reliable—yet.
Here is how a friend of mine who does his research put it to me: